LEC052021. Gayathri M G. "Critical significance of the Ides of March".
Critical
significance of the ‘Ides of March’ in Julius Caesar
Julius Caesar is a historical play
and one of the famous tragedies by William Shakespeare. The phrase the ‘ides of
March’ in the play would go down in history to be associated with bad luck. The
ides of March(the fifteenth of March) had religious significance in Roman
calendar. It was also considered by Romans as the deadline to settle debts. Unfortunately,
Caesar’s assassination on the said day results in the belief that it is a
harbinger for misfortune, an idea which was promoted by the superstitious Roman
society. “The Ides of March is considered to be pivotal in Roman history as the
death of Caesar contributed to the transition from the historical period known
as the Roman Republic to the Roman Empire” (The Literary Significance).
The soothsayer’s warning “Beware the
ides of March” appears in Act 1 Scene 2 of Julius Caesar. The phrase
foreshadows the impending doom of Caesar. Caesar hears it first as he takes his
victory march in the street. The soothsayer is called forward by him. When
the soothsayer repeats his warning, Caesar dismisses him stating “He is a
dreamer. Let us leave him. Pass!” Despite this remark, Caesar sees a soothsayer
before the ides who warns him about the tragedy which would happen. Still, he goes
to the Senate.
The play is abound in superstition
adding to the warning which signifies the main action of the play. Calpurnia,
wife of Caesar, dreams of her husband’s statue overflowing with blood like a
fountain. She also saw several smiling Romans bathing their hands in it. When
this dream doesn’t change Caesar’s decision to go the Senate, Calpurnia recounts the numerous horrid
sights seen in the city earlier that night – the dead walked in the streets,
the graves cracked open, a lioness gave birth in the streets and lightning
flashed in the sky. Despite the fear of his wife who is generally not superstitious,
he remains unperturbed.
Pride acts as the hamartia of Caesar
which leads to his fall. Caesar refuses to pay heed to the soothsayer’s warning
and decides to ignore the other omens pointing to his demise. As John T. Ramsey
states in his article “ ‘Beware the Ides of March!’:An Astrological Prediction?”
the seer is identified as a haruspex named Spurinna(pp. 440-454). Caesar belonged
to a period where Etruscan soothsayers where never ignored in their prophecies.
Still, not only does he disregard it but also mocks the soothsayer.
CAESAR. The ides of March are come.
SOOTHSAYER. Ay, Caesar; but not
gone.
When he goes to
the Senate, he is stabbed to death by the conspirators. His pride led to a fate
which could not be changed despite several interventions.
The ‘ides of March’ turns out to be
a phrase which significantly points to the major incidents in the play.
Calpurnia’s dream delineating Caesar’s murder and the several supernatural occurrences
which happen on the eve of the said day also point to the significance of the
warning. The element of foreshadowing is heavily used in the play to show how
fate overpowers free will leading to the assassination of one of the greatest
figures in Roman history.
Works cited
Ramsey, John T. "‘Beware The Ides Of March!’: An
Astrological Prediction?". The Classical Quarterly, vol 50,
no. 2, 2000, pp. 440-454. Accessed on 13 Jan 2021.
Shakespeare,
William. Julius Caesar. M G Publishers, 2015. Print.
“The Literary Significance of The Ides of March.” The Indian Express, 15 March, 2020. https://indianexpress.com/article/books-and-literature/the-literary-significance-of-ides-of-march-6315265/. Accessed on 13 Jan 2021.
The argument has been clearly stated. Use of linking statements could connect the paragraphs better. Mentioning the source while indenting has been missed.
ReplyDeleteThe significance of 'ides of march' is stated clearly and the role of superstition is highlighted.
ReplyDeleteIn the first line the name of the play is not italicized. In the fourth paragraph, in-text citation is given as 'pp. 440-454'; simply give the page number without 'pp'. Citation is not given for the indented portion.
The essay is well written with suitable introduction and conclusion. In text citation is not properly done at some places.
ReplyDeleteThe topic has been properly analyzed with an elaboration of the keywords and the events. The statements are presented in a systematic manner with a proper title, argument, hypothesis and supporting statements. There is transition in paragraphs but some linking words could have made it smooth. The work cited is in the MLA format but the hanging indent is not applied. The in-text citation has been neglected in some cases.
ReplyDeleteThe argument is presented very well. Except the errors in the in text citation, the structure and format of the essay are good.
ReplyDeleteThe language and choice of words make the essay a smooth read. The opening line felt a bit vague as it does not hit the topic. The hypothesis is not precise, but the essay does justice to the same. The capitalisation of content words in the title is imperfect: the word “significance”. ‘Tense ’shifts from present to past tense at times. The use of linking sentences are not satisfactory. Longer paragraphs would have helped to better establish the ideas, as it feels a bit rushed, at present. In-text citation is missing in the dialogue between Caesar and soothsayer; and paragraph separation with indentation is unnecessary for a 2-line quotation. The play is not well-concluded: the concluding paragraphs introduce new topics which are then left unexplained.
ReplyDeletecorrection: the concluding paragraph introduces new topics...
DeleteThe essay is well structured. The hypothesis and the arguments are presented effectively.The title of the work in the first sentence should be italicized.The indented portion is not cited.There are slight grammatical errors in some places.
ReplyDeleteThe essay successfully conveyed the major ideas discussed. The historical significance of the Ides of March is explained thoroughly initially. The vocabulary is highly effective but, the linking sentences could have been more subtle, rather than the abrupt transitions. Please ensure that the MLA stylesheet is rightly followed. The in-text citations aren't mentioned at a few places in the essay. The conclusion is giving rise to another topic of discussion, and hence, the concluding part could have been penned in a better way.
ReplyDelete